English
  • 简体中文
Mainnet
BSV
  • BSV
  • mBSV
  • Bits
  • Sat

Transaction

a56e175d0aa69f0720ea7dab2e76f84b42608616fe0c0c1424f671e7b05ee88e
( - )
246,154
2019-07-17 19:51:49
1
42,189 B

2 Outputs

Total Output:
  • j"19HxigV4QyBv3tHpQVcUEQyq1pzZVdoAutM®£<!DOCTYPE html> <!-- saved from url=(0038)https://www.oyez.org/cases/2010/09-993 --> <html xml:lang="en" lang="en" dir="ltr" class="js flexbox flexboxlegacy canvas canvastext webgl no-touch geolocation postmessage websqldatabase indexeddb hashchange history draganddrop websockets rgba hsla multiplebgs backgroundsize borderimage borderradius boxshadow textshadow opacity cssanimations csscolumns cssgradients cssreflections csstransforms csstransforms3d csstransitions fontface generatedcontent video audio localstorage sessionstorage webworkers applicationcache svg inlinesvg smil svgclippaths ng-scope" data-ng-app="oyezorgApp"><head ng-controller="OyHeadCtrl" class="ng-scope"><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8"><style type="text/css">@charset "UTF-8";[ng\:cloak],[ng-cloak],[data-ng-cloak],[x-ng-cloak],.ng-cloak,.x-ng-cloak,.ng-hide:not(.ng-hide-animate){display:none !important;}ng\:form{display:block;}</style> <title class="ng-binding">PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing | Oyez</title> <!--<base href="/index.html">--><base href="."> <meta name="description" content="A case in which the Court held that generic drug makers cannot be sued for not warning about potentially dangerous side effects on their drug labels, even when they follow federal rules that only require their labels to match those of their brand-name equivalents."> <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,user-scalable=0"> <meta name="fragment" content="!"> <meta property="og:title" content="PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing"> <meta property="og:site_name" content="Oyez"> <meta property="og:description" contet="A case in which the Court held that generic drug makers cannot be sued for not warning about potentially dangerous side effects on their drug labels, even when they follow federal rules that only require their labels to match those of their brand-name equivalents."> <meta property="og:locale" content="en_US"> <meta property="fb:app_id" content="131510300343784"> <!-- Place favicon.ico and apple-touch-icon.png in the root directory --> <link rel="stylesheet" href="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/vendor.724e8f17.css"> <link rel="stylesheet" href="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/main.052b3625.css"> <!-- Google Tag Manager --> <script type="text/javascript" async="" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/analytics.js.download"></script><script src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/analytics.js.download"></script><script async="" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/gtm.js.download"></script><script>dataLayer = [];</script> <script>(function(w,d,s,l,i){w[l]=w[l]||[];w[l].push({'gtm.start': new Date().getTime(),event:'gtm.js'});var f=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0], j=d.createElement(s),dl=l!='dataLayer'?'&l='+l:'';j.async=true;j.src= 'https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id='+i+dl;f.parentNode.insertBefore(j,f); })(window,document,'script','dataLayer','GTM-K9XPQSX');</script> <!-- End Google Tag Manager --> </head><body eui-index="node" ng-controller="OyPageCtrl" ng-class="{home: isHome(), &#39;not-home&#39;: (! isHome())}" class="ng-scope not-home"> <!--[if lte IE 9]> <p class="browsehappy">You are using an <strong>outdated</strong> browser no longer supported by Oyez. Please <a href="http://browsehappy.com/">upgrade your browser</a> to improve your experience.</p> <![endif]--> <!-- Add your site or application content here --> <div class="container off-canvas-wrap ng-isolate-scope"> <div class="inner-wrap"> <!-- ngIf: (! isApp) --><div class="oy-overhead ng-scope" ng-if="(! isApp)"> <div class="oy-overhead-wrapper"> <div class="nav-bar-wrapper"> <nav> <ul> <!-- ngRepeat: link in navLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in navLinks" class="oyez"> <a ng-href="/" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" href="https://www.oyez.org/"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">Oyez</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: link.subnav --><ul ng-if="link.subnav" class="ng-scope"> <!-- ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --><li ng-repeat="subLink in link.subnav" class="about"> <a ng-href="about" ng-attr-target="{{subLink.target ? subLink.target : undefined}}" href="https://www.oyez.org/about"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="subLink.caption">About</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: subLink.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --><li ng-repeat="subLink in link.subnav" class="license"> <a ng-href="license" ng-attr-target="{{subLink.target ? subLink.target : undefined}}" href="https://www.oyez.org/license"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="subLink.caption">License</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: subLink.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --><li ng-repeat="subLink in link.subnav" class="lawyer-directory"> <a ng-href="http://lawyers.oyez.org/" ng-attr-target="{{subLink.target ? subLink.target : undefined}}" href="http://lawyers.oyez.org/" target="_blank"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="subLink.caption">Lawyer Directory</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: subLink.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --><li ng-repeat="subLink in link.subnav" class="projects"> <a ng-href="" ng-attr-target="{{subLink.target ? subLink.target : undefined}}"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="subLink.caption">Projects</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: subLink.subnav --><ul ng-if="subLink.subnav" class="nested-subnav ng-scope"> <!-- ngRepeat: nestedLink in subLink.subnav --><li ng-repeat="nestedLink in subLink.subnav" class="shifting-scales"> <a ng-href="http://projects.oyez.org/shifting-scales/" ng-attr-target="{{nestedLink.target ? nestedLink.target : undefined}}" href="http://projects.oyez.org/shifting-scales/" target="_blank"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="nestedLink.caption">Shifting Scales</span> </a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: nestedLink in subLink.subnav --><li ng-repeat="nestedLink in subLink.subnav" class="body-politic"> <a ng-href="http://projects.oyez.org/body-politic/" ng-attr-target="{{nestedLink.target ? nestedLink.target : undefined}}" href="http://projects.oyez.org/body-politic/" target="_blank"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="nestedLink.caption">Body Politic</span> </a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: nestedLink in subLink.subnav --> </ul><!-- end ngIf: subLink.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --><li ng-repeat="subLink in link.subnav" class="site-feedback"> <a ng-href="feedback" ng-attr-target="{{subLink.target ? subLink.target : undefined}}" href="https://www.oyez.org/feedback"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="subLink.caption">Site Feedback</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: subLink.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --><li ng-repeat="subLink in link.subnav" class="support"> <a ng-href="https://give.law.cornell.edu/checkout/donation?eid=107610" ng-attr-target="{{subLink.target ? subLink.target : undefined}}" href="https://give.law.cornell.edu/checkout/donation?eid=107610" target="_blank"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="subLink.caption">Support Oyez &amp; LII</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: subLink.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --> </ul><!-- end ngIf: link.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in navLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in navLinks" class="lii-resources"> <a ng-href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/home" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/home" target="_blank"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">LII Supreme Court Resources</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: link.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in navLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in navLinks" class="justia-sc-center"> <a ng-href="https://supreme.justia.com/" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" href="https://supreme.justia.com/" target="_blank"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">Justia Supreme Court Center</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: link.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in navLinks --> </ul> </nav> </div> <div class="search-wrapper"> <div class="oy-search-bar ng-isolate-scope"> <input type="search" ng-model="query" ng-keypress="onKeypress($event)" placeholder="Search" class="ng-pristine ng-untouched ng-valid"> </div> </div> </div> </div><!-- end ngIf: (! isApp) --> <!-- ngIf: (! isApp) --><div class="oy-navigation ng-scope" ng-if="(! isApp)"> <!-- Overhead navigation bar, for large screens --> <div class="nav-bar"> <div class="inner"> <h1 class="logo"><a ng-href="/" href="https://www.oyez.org/"> <img ng-src="images/nav/logo_black.beb12aef.png" alt="Oyez" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/logo_black.beb12aef.png"> </a></h1> <nav><ul> <!-- ngRepeat: link in navLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in navLinks" class="cases"> <a ng-href="cases" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" href="https://www.oyez.org/cases"> <span class="icon"></span> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">Cases</span> </a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in navLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in navLinks" class="justices"> <a ng-href="justices" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" href="https://www.oyez.org/justices"> <span class="icon"></span> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">Justices</span> </a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in navLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in navLinks" class="tour"> <a ng-href="tour" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" href="https://www.oyez.org/tour"> <span class="icon"></span> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">Tour</span> </a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in navLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in navLinks" class="iscotus"> <a ng-href="http://now.iscotus.org/" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" href="http://now.iscotus.org/" target="_blank"> <span class="icon"></span> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">News</span> </a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in navLinks --> </ul></nav> </div> </div> <!-- Off-canvas navigation, for small screens --> <div class="off-canvas-nav"> <div class="tab-bar"> <section class="left-small"> <a class="left-off-canvas-toggle" ng-click="showSearch=false"> <span class="left-menu">&nbsp;</span> </a> </section> <section class="middle tab-bar-section"> <h1 class="logo"><a ng-href="/" href="https://www.oyez.org/"> <img ng-src="images/nav/logo_white.6e3f74d1.png" alt="Oyez" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/logo_white.6e3f74d1.png"> </a></h1> </section> <section class="right-small"> <a class="search-wrapper-toggle" ng-click="showSearch=!showSearch"> <span class="search-toggle">&nbsp;</span> </a> </section> <!-- ngIf: showSearch --> </div> <nav class="left-off-canvas-menu"> <ul class="off-canvas-list"> <!-- ngRepeat: link in topnavLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in topnavLinks" class="cases" ng-class="{&#39;subNav&#39;: link.subnav}"> <a ng-href="cases" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" ng-class="{&#39;parentLink&#39;: link.subnav}" href="https://www.oyez.org/cases"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">Cases</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: link.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in topnavLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in topnavLinks" class="justices" ng-class="{&#39;subNav&#39;: link.subnav}"> <a ng-href="justices" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" ng-class="{&#39;parentLink&#39;: link.subnav}" href="https://www.oyez.org/justices"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">Justices</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: link.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in topnavLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in topnavLinks" class="about subNav" ng-class="{&#39;subNav&#39;: link.subnav}"> <a ng-href="about" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" ng-class="{&#39;parentLink&#39;: link.subnav}" href="https://www.oyez.org/about" class="parentLink"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">About</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: link.subnav --><ul ng-if="link.subnav" class="ng-scope"> <!-- ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --><li ng-repeat="subLink in link.subnav" class="license"> <a ng-href="license" ng-attr-target="{{subLink.target || undefined}}" href="https://www.oyez.org/license"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="subLink.caption">License</span> </a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --><li ng-repeat="subLink in link.subnav" class="site-feedback"> <a ng-href="feedback" ng-attr-target="{{subLink.target || undefined}}" href="https://www.oyez.org/feedback"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="subLink.caption">Site Feedback</span> </a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --><li ng-repeat="subLink in link.subnav" class="support"> <a ng-href="https://give.law.cornell.edu/checkout/donation?eid=107610" ng-attr-target="{{subLink.target || undefined}}" href="https://give.law.cornell.edu/checkout/donation?eid=107610" target="_blank"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="subLink.caption">Support</span> </a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --><li ng-repeat="subLink in link.subnav" class="tour"> <a ng-href="tour" ng-attr-target="{{subLink.target || undefined}}" href="https://www.oyez.org/tour"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="subLink.caption">Tour</span> </a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --><li ng-repeat="subLink in link.subnav" class="iscotus"> <a ng-href="http://now.iscotus.org/" ng-attr-target="{{subLink.target || undefined}}" href="http://now.iscotus.org/" target="_blank"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="subLink.caption">News</span> </a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --> </ul><!-- end ngIf: link.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in topnavLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in topnavLinks" class="projects subNav" ng-class="{&#39;subNav&#39;: link.subnav}"> <a ng-href="" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" ng-class="{&#39;parentLink&#39;: link.subnav}" class="parentLink"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">Projects</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: link.subnav --><ul ng-if="link.subnav" class="ng-scope"> <!-- ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --><li ng-repeat="subLink in link.subnav" class="shifting-scales"> <a ng-href="http://projects.oyez.org/shifting-scales/" ng-attr-target="{{subLink.target || undefined}}" href="http://projects.oyez.org/shifting-scales/" target="_blank"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="subLink.caption">Shifting Scales</span> </a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --><li ng-repeat="subLink in link.subnav" class="body-politic"> <a ng-href="http://projects.oyez.org/body-politic/" ng-attr-target="{{subLink.target || undefined}}" href="http://projects.oyez.org/body-politic/" target="_blank"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="subLink.caption">Body Politic</span> </a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: subLink in link.subnav --> </ul><!-- end ngIf: link.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in topnavLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in topnavLinks" class="lawyer-directory" ng-class="{&#39;subNav&#39;: link.subnav}"> <a ng-href="http://lawyers.oyez.org/" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" ng-class="{&#39;parentLink&#39;: link.subnav}" href="http://lawyers.oyez.org/"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">Lawyer Directory</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: link.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in topnavLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in topnavLinks" class="lii-resources" ng-class="{&#39;subNav&#39;: link.subnav}"> <a ng-href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/home" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" ng-class="{&#39;parentLink&#39;: link.subnav}" href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/home" target="_blank"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">LII Supreme Court Resources</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: link.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in topnavLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in topnavLinks" class="justia-sc-center" ng-class="{&#39;subNav&#39;: link.subnav}"> <a ng-href="https://supreme.justia.com/" ng-attr-target="{{link.target || undefined}}" ng-class="{&#39;parentLink&#39;: link.subnav}" href="https://supreme.justia.com/" target="_blank"> <span class="caption ng-binding" ng-bind-html="link.caption">Justia Supreme Court Center</span> </a> <!-- ngIf: link.subnav --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in topnavLinks --> </ul> </nav> </div> </div><!-- end ngIf: (! isApp) --> <!-- ngView: --><div class="page ng-scope" data-ng-view="" autoscroll="true"><div> <script type="text/ng-template" id="template/modal/backdrop.html"><div class="reveal-modal-bg fade" ng-class="{in: animate}" ng-click="close($event)" style="display: block"></div></script> <script type="text/ng-template" id="template/modal/window.html"><div tabindex="-1" class="oy-modal fade {{ windowClass }}" ng-class="{in: animate}" style="display: block; visibility: visible"> <div class="oy-modal-wrapper" ng-transclude></div> </div></script> <script type="text/ng-template" id="modal.html"><a class="close" ng-click="close()"></a> <iframe class="oy-modal-iframe" src="{{modalUrl}}"></iframe></script> </div> <main class="case flex ng-scope"> <div class="blue oy-sidebar ng-isolate-scope" ng-class="class" title="PLIVA, Inc. &lt;span class=&quot;v&quot;&gt;v.&lt;/span&gt; Mensing"> <div class="full-sidebar"> <div class="inner"> <!-- ngIf: title --><h1 ng-bind-html="title" ng-if="title" class="ng-binding ng-scope">PLIVA, Inc. <span class="v">v.</span> Mensing</h1><!-- end ngIf: title --> <div ng-transclude=""> <div class="ng-scope"> <div class="media"> <!-- ngIf: case.oral_argument_audio[0] || case.opinion_announcement[0] --><h2 ng-if="case.oral_argument_audio[0] || case.opinion_announcement[0]" class="ng-scope">Media</h2><!-- end ngIf: case.oral_argument_audio[0] || case.opinion_announcement[0] --> <ul> <!-- ngRepeat: audio in case.oral_argument_audio --><li ng-repeat="audio in case.oral_argument_audio" class="audio ng-scope"> <!-- ngIf: audio.unavailable --> <!-- ngIf: (! audio.unavailable) --><a ng-click="openModal()" ng-if="(! audio.unavailable)" caption="Oral Argument - March 30, 2011" iframe-url="https://apps.oyez.org/player/#/roberts6/oral_argument_audio/22229" class="ng-binding ng-isolate-scope">Oral Argument - March 30, 2011</a><!-- end ngIf: (! audio.unavailable) --> <!-- ngIf: audio.public_note --> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: audio in case.oral_argument_audio --> <!-- ngRepeat: audio in case.opinion_announcement --><li ng-repeat="audio in case.opinion_announcement" class="audio ng-scope"> <a ng-click="openModal()" caption="Opinion Announcement - June 23, 2011" iframe-url="https://apps.oyez.org/player/#/roberts6/opinion_announcement_audio/22990" class="ng-binding ng-isolate-scope">Opinion Announcement - June 23, 2011</a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: audio in case.opinion_announcement --> </ul> </div> <div class="documents"> <!-- ngIf: case.written_opinion[0] --><h2 ng-if="case.written_opinion[0]" class="ng-scope">Opinions</h2><!-- end ngIf: case.written_opinion[0] --> <ul> <!-- ngRepeat: document in case.written_opinion | orderBy:sortOpinions --><!-- ngIf: document.justia_opinion_url --><li ng-if="document.justia_opinion_url" ng-repeat="document in case.written_opinion | orderBy:sortOpinions" class="document ng-scope"> <a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/564/09-993/#tab-opinion-1963610" target="_blank" title="Syllabus" class="ng-binding"> Syllabus <!-- ngIf: document.judge_last_name --> </a> </li><!-- end ngIf: document.justia_opinion_url --><!-- end ngRepeat: document in case.written_opinion | orderBy:sortOpinions --><!-- ngIf: document.justia_opinion_url --><li ng-if="document.justia_opinion_url" ng-repeat="document in case.written_opinion | orderBy:sortOpinions" class="document ng-scope"> <a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/564/09-993/#tab-opinion-1963611" target="_blank" title="Opinion of the Court" class="ng-binding"> Opinion of the Court <!-- ngIf: document.judge_last_name --><span ng-if="document.judge_last_name" class="ng-binding ng-scope">(Thomas)</span><!-- end ngIf: document.judge_last_name --> </a> </li><!-- end ngIf: document.justia_opinion_url --><!-- end ngRepeat: document in case.written_opinion | orderBy:sortOpinions --><!-- ngIf: document.justia_opinion_url --><li ng-if="document.justia_opinion_url" ng-repeat="document in case.written_opinion | orderBy:sortOpinions" class="document ng-scope"> <a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/564/09-993/#tab-opinion-1963609" target="_blank" title="Dissenting opinion" class="ng-binding"> Dissenting opinion <!-- ngIf: document.judge_last_name --><span ng-if="document.judge_last_name" class="ng-binding ng-scope">(Sotomayor)</span><!-- end ngIf: document.judge_last_name --> </a> </li><!-- end ngIf: document.justia_opinion_url --><!-- end ngRepeat: document in case.written_opinion | orderBy:sortOpinions --> </ul> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </div> <article class="content ng-isolate-scope" oy-height-report="scrollHeight"> <div class="content-inner"> <aside> <div class="row"> <div class="cell ng-binding"> <h3 class="ng-binding">Petitioner</h3> PLIVA, Inc., et al. </div> <div class="cell ng-binding"> <h3 class="ng-binding">Respondent</h3> Gladys Mensing </div> <!-- ngIf: case.location --><div class="cell ng-scope" ng-if="case.location"> <h3>Location</h3> <a ng-click="openModal()" caption="Actavis Elizabeth LLC" iframe-url="https://www.google.com/maps/embed/v1/search?key=AIzaSyDLn50qaW3AmnPxW-RpWAvpi7bbrL5wy3k&amp;q=40.664962,-74.235743" class="ng-binding ng-isolate-scope">Actavis Elizabeth LLC</a> </div><!-- end ngIf: case.location --> </div> <div class="row"> <div class="cell ng-binding"> <h3>Docket no.</h3> 09-993 </div> <div class="cell"> <h3>Decided by</h3> <!-- ngIf: case.decided_by --><span ng-if="case.decided_by" class="ng-scope"><a href="https://www.oyez.org/courts?court=Roberts%20Court" class="ng-binding">Roberts Court </a></span><!-- end ngIf: case.decided_by --> <!-- ngIf: (! case.decided_by) --> </div> <!-- ngIf: case.lower_court --><div class="cell ng-binding ng-scope" ng-if="case.lower_court"> <h3>Lower court</h3> United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit </div><!-- end ngIf: case.lower_court --> </div> <div class="row"> <div class="cell"> <!-- ngIf: case.citation --><div class="subcell ng-scope" ng-if="case.citation"> <h3>Citation</h3> <!-- ngIf: case.citation.volume --><a ng-href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/564/09-993" target="_blank" ng-transclude="" ng-if="case.citation.volume" citation="case.citation" docket="case.docket_number" class="ng-isolate-scope" href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/564/09-993"> <span ng-bind-html="case.citation | oyCitation:&#39;usreports&#39;" class="ng-binding ng-scope">564&nbsp;US&nbsp;_&nbsp;(2011)</span> </a><!-- end ngIf: case.citation.volume --> <!-- ngIf: (! case.citation.volume) --> </div><!-- end ngIf: case.citation --> <!-- ngRepeat: chron in case.timeline --><div class="subcell ng-binding ng-scope" ng-repeat="chron in case.timeline"> <h3 class="ng-binding">Granted</h3> <!-- ngIf: date == null --> <!-- ngIf: date != null --><div ng-if="date != null" class="ng-binding ng-scope">Dec 10, 2010</div><!-- end ngIf: date != null --> </div><!-- end ngRepeat: chron in case.timeline --><div class="subcell ng-binding ng-scope" ng-repeat="chron in case.timeline"> <h3 class="ng-binding">Argued</h3> <!-- ngIf: date == null --> <!-- ngIf: date != null --><div ng-if="date != null" class="ng-binding ng-scope">Mar 30, 2011</div><!-- end ngIf: date != null --> </div><!-- end ngRepeat: chron in case.timeline --><div class="subcell ng-binding ng-scope" ng-repeat="chron in case.timeline"> <h3 class="ng-binding">Decided</h3> <!-- ngIf: date == null --> <!-- ngIf: date != null --><div ng-if="date != null" class="ng-binding ng-scope">Jun 23, 2011</div><!-- end ngIf: date != null --> </div><!-- end ngRepeat: chron in case.timeline --> </div> <div class="cell"> <!-- ngIf: case.advocates --><div class="subcell ng-scope" ng-if="case.advocates"> <h3>Advocates</h3> <!-- ngRepeat: advocate in case.advocates --><div class="advocate ng-scope" ng-repeat="advocate in case.advocates"> <a ng-href="advocates/jay_p_lefkowitz" class="ng-binding" href="https://www.oyez.org/advocates/jay_p_lefkowitz">Jay P. Lefkowitz</a> <span class="description ng-binding">for the petitioners</span> </div><!-- end ngRepeat: advocate in case.advocates --><div class="advocate ng-scope" ng-repeat="advocate in case.advocates"> <a ng-href="advocates/louis_m_bograd" class="ng-binding" href="https://www.oyez.org/advocates/louis_m_bograd">Louis M. Bograd</a> <span class="description ng-binding">for the respondents</span> </div><!-- end ngRepeat: advocate in case.advocates --><div class="advocate ng-scope" ng-repeat="advocate in case.advocates"> <a ng-href="advocates/edwin_s_kneedler" class="ng-binding" href="https://www.oyez.org/advocates/edwin_s_kneedler">Edwin S. Kneedler</a> <span class="description ng-binding">Deputy Solicitor General, Department of Justice, for the United States as amicus curiae, supporting the respondents</span> </div><!-- end ngRepeat: advocate in case.advocates --> </div><!-- end ngIf: case.advocates --> </div> </div> </aside> <!-- ngIf: case.facts_of_the_case --><section class="abstract ng-scope" ng-if="case.facts_of_the_case"> <h2>Facts of the case</h2> <div ng-bind-html="case.facts_of_the_case" class="ng-binding"><p>Gladys Mensing took the drug metoclopramide for four years to help fight diabetic gastroparesis. She filed a lawsuit against the generic drug's manufacturers and distributors, contending that the drug gave her a severe neurological movement disorder, tardive dyskinesia, but none of the generic drug's manufacturers and distributors made any effort to include warnings on the label.</p> <p>Metoclopramide manufacturers Pliva Inc. and Actavis Elizabeth LLC asked for the lawsuit to be thrown out, arguing that government regulations require thp to have the same label on metoclopramide as is on its brand-name equivalent, Reglan. Reglan did not have a warning about tardive dyskinesia while Mensing was taking metoclopramide.</p> <p>A federal judge on the U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota agreed, saying the lawsuit was pre-ppted by the federal regulations requiring the two labels to match. But the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit overturned that ruling, holding that more should have been done to warn consumers about possible risks.</p> </div> </section><!-- end ngIf: case.facts_of_the_case --> <!-- ngIf: case.question --><section class="abstract ng-scope" ng-if="case.question"> <h2>Question</h2> <div ng-bind-html="case.question" class="ng-binding"><p>Can generic drug makers be sued for not warning about potentially dangerous side effects on their drug labels even when they follow federal rules that only require their labels to match those of their brand-name equivalents?</p> </div> </section><!-- end ngIf: case.question --> <section class="abstract"> <!-- ngIf: case.conclusion --><h2 ng-if="case.conclusion" class="ng-scope">Conclusion</h2><!-- end ngIf: case.conclusion --> <div class="decisions" ng-show="case.decisions"> <div ng-show="case.decisions" class="sort-links"> <span class="label">Sort:&nbsp;</span> <ul> <!-- ngRepeat: link in decisionSortLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in decisionSortLinks" class="ng-scope"> <a ng-class="{active: link.isActive()}" ng-click="link.callback()" class="ng-binding active">by seniority</a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in decisionSortLinks --><li ng-repeat="link in decisionSortLinks" class="ng-scope"> <a ng-class="{active: link.isActive()}" ng-click="link.callback()" class="ng-binding">by ideology</a> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: link in decisionSortLinks --> </ul> </div> <div ng-show="case.decisions.length &gt; 1" class="decision-cycle ng-binding ng-hide"> <a class="prev" ng-click="previousDecision()">&lt;&lt;</a> decision 1 of 1 <a class="next" ng-click="nextDecision()">&gt;&gt;</a> </div> <div class="oy-carousel ng-isolate-scope" current-seat="currentDecision"> <ul ng-transclude="" ng-class="{set: isSet, reversing: isReversing, &#39;single-seat&#39;: (typeof(seats) != &#39;undefined&#39;) &amp;&amp; (seats.length == 1)}" class="set single-seat"> <!-- ngRepeat: (index, decision) in case.decisions --><li ng-transclude="" class="next" ng-repeat="(index, decision) in case.decisions"> <figure class="oy-decision ng-isolate-scope" decision="decision" order-by="seniority"> <figcaption class="decision-description"> <h3 class="vote-description"> <!-- ngIf: (decision.minority_vote > 0) && ((decision.decision_type == 'majority opinion') || (decision.decision_type == 'plurality opinion')) --><span class="vote ng-binding ng-scope" ng-if="(decision.minority_vote &gt; 0) &amp;&amp; ((decision.decision_type == &#39;majority opinion&#39;) || (decision.decision_type == &#39;plurality opinion&#39;))">5–4 decision</span><!-- end ngIf: (decision.minority_vote > 0) && ((decision.decision_type == 'majority opinion') || (decision.decision_type == 'plurality opinion')) --> <!-- ngIf: (decision.minority_vote == 0) && ((decision.decision_type == 'majority opinion') || (decision.decision_type == 'plurality opinion')) --> <!-- ngIf: ! ((decision.decision_type == 'majority opinion') || (decision.decision_type == 'plurality opinion')) --> <!-- ngIf: decision.winning_party --><span class="winner ng-binding ng-scope" ng-if="decision.winning_party"> for PLIVA, Inc. et al.</span><!-- end ngIf: decision.winning_party --> <!-- ngIf: decision.author && (decision.decision_type != 'per curiam') --><span class="author ng-binding ng-scope" ng-if="decision.author &amp;&amp; (decision.decision_type != &#39;per curiam&#39;)"><br>majority opinion by Clarence Thomas</span><!-- end ngIf: decision.author && (decision.decision_type != 'per curiam') --> <!-- ngIf: decision.decision_type == 'per curiam' --> </h3> <!-- ngIf: decision.description --> </figcaption> <div class="decision-image"> <!-- ngRepeat: vote in decision.votes --><figure ng-class="[vote.vote, vote.orderClass]" ng-repeat="vote in decision.votes" class="ng-scope majority first"> <div class="thumbnail"> <img ng-src="https://api.oyez.org/sites/default/files/images/people/john_g_roberts_jr/john_g_roberts_jr.thumb.png" alt="John G. Roberts, Jr." src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/john_g_roberts_jr.thumb.png"> </div> <figcaption> <span class="long ng-binding">John G. Roberts, Jr.</span> <span class="short ng-binding">Roberts</span> </figcaption> </figure><!-- end ngRepeat: vote in decision.votes --><figure ng-class="[vote.vote, vote.orderClass]" ng-repeat="vote in decision.votes" class="ng-scope majority second"> <div class="thumbnail"> <img ng-src="https://api.oyez.org/sites/default/files/images/people/antonin_scalia/antonin_scalia.thumb.png" alt="Antonin Scalia" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/antonin_scalia.thumb.png"> </div> <figcaption> <span class="long ng-binding">Antonin Scalia</span> <span class="short ng-binding">Scalia</span> </figcaption> </figure><!-- end ngRepeat: vote in decision.votes --><figure ng-class="[vote.vote, vote.orderClass]" ng-repeat="vote in decision.votes" class="ng-scope majority third"> <div class="thumbnail"> <img ng-src="https://api.oyez.org/sites/default/files/images/people/anthony_m_kennedy/anthony_m_kennedy.thumb.png" alt="Anthony M. Kennedy" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/anthony_m_kennedy.thumb.png"> </div> <figcaption> <span class="long ng-binding">Anthony M. Kennedy</span> <span class="short ng-binding">Kennedy</span> </figcaption> </figure><!-- end ngRepeat: vote in decision.votes --><figure ng-class="[vote.vote, vote.orderClass]" ng-repeat="vote in decision.votes" class="ng-scope majority fourth"> <div class="thumbnail"> <img ng-src="https://api.oyez.org/sites/default/files/images/people/clarence_thomas/clarence_thomas.thumb.png" alt="Clarence Thomas" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/clarence_thomas.thumb.png"> </div> <figcaption> <span class="long ng-binding">Clarence Thomas</span> <span class="short ng-binding">Thomas</span> </figcaption> </figure><!-- end ngRepeat: vote in decision.votes --><figure ng-class="[vote.vote, vote.orderClass]" ng-repeat="vote in decision.votes" class="ng-scope minority fifth"> <div class="thumbnail"> <img ng-src="https://api.oyez.org/sites/default/files/images/people/ruth_bader_ginsburg/ruth_bader_ginsburg.thumb.png" alt="Ruth Bader Ginsburg" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/ruth_bader_ginsburg.thumb.png"> </div> <figcaption> <span class="long ng-binding">Ruth Bader Ginsburg</span> <span class="short ng-binding">Ginsburg</span> </figcaption> </figure><!-- end ngRepeat: vote in decision.votes --><figure ng-class="[vote.vote, vote.orderClass]" ng-repeat="vote in decision.votes" class="ng-scope minority sixth"> <div class="thumbnail"> <img ng-src="https://api.oyez.org/sites/default/files/images/people/stephen_g_breyer/stephen_g_breyer.thumb.png" alt="Stephen G. Breyer" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/stephen_g_breyer.thumb.png"> </div> <figcaption> <span class="long ng-binding">Stephen G. Breyer</span> <span class="short ng-binding">Breyer</span> </figcaption> </figure><!-- end ngRepeat: vote in decision.votes --><figure ng-class="[vote.vote, vote.orderClass]" ng-repeat="vote in decision.votes" class="ng-scope majority seventh"> <div class="thumbnail"> <img ng-src="https://api.oyez.org/sites/default/files/images/people/samuel_alito_jr/samuel_alito_jr.thumb.png" alt="Samuel A. Alito, Jr." src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/samuel_alito_jr.thumb.png"> </div> <figcaption> <span class="long ng-binding">Samuel A. Alito, Jr.</span> <span class="short ng-binding">Alito</span> </figcaption> </figure><!-- end ngRepeat: vote in decision.votes --><figure ng-class="[vote.vote, vote.orderClass]" ng-repeat="vote in decision.votes" class="ng-scope minority eighth"> <div class="thumbnail"> <img ng-src="https://api.oyez.org/sites/default/files/images/people/sonia_sotomayor/sonia_sotomayor.thumb.png" alt="Sonia Sotomayor" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/sonia_sotomayor.thumb.png"> </div> <figcaption> <span class="long ng-binding">Sonia Sotomayor</span> <span class="short ng-binding">Sotomayor</span> </figcaption> </figure><!-- end ngRepeat: vote in decision.votes --><figure ng-class="[vote.vote, vote.orderClass]" ng-repeat="vote in decision.votes" class="ng-scope minority ninth"> <div class="thumbnail"> <img ng-src="https://api.oyez.org/sites/default/files/images/people/elena_kagan/elena_kagan.thumb.png" alt="Elena Kagan" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/elena_kagan.thumb.png"> </div> <figcaption> <span class="long ng-binding">Elena Kagan</span> <span class="short ng-binding">Kagan</span> </figcaption> </figure><!-- end ngRepeat: vote in decision.votes --> </div> </figure> </li><!-- end ngRepeat: (index, decision) in case.decisions --> </ul> </div> </div> <!-- ngIf: case.conclusion --><div ng-if="case.conclusion" ng-bind-html="case.conclusion" class="ng-binding ng-scope"><p>No. The Supreme Court reversed the lower court order in an opinion by Justice Clarence Thomas. Justice Kennedy joined the opinion in part. "We defer to the FDA's interpretation of its CBE and generic labeling regulations," Justice Thomas wrote. Meanwhile, Justice Sonia Sotomayor dissented, joined by Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer and Elena Kagan. "We have traditionally held defendants claiming impossibility to a demanding standard: Until today, the mere possibility of impossibility had not been enough to establish pre-emption," Sotomayor wrote.</p> </div><!-- end ngIf: case.conclusion --> </section> <div class="oy-cite ng-isolate-scope" title="PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing"> <h2>Cite this page</h2> <ul> <li><a ng-class="{active: currentFormat == &#39;APA&#39;}" ng-click="currentFormat = &#39;APA&#39;" class="">APA</a></li> <li><a ng-class="{active: currentFormat == &#39;Bluebook&#39;}" ng-click="currentFormat = &#39;Bluebook&#39;" class="">Bluebook</a></li> <li><a ng-class="{active: currentFormat == &#39;Chicago&#39;}" ng-click="currentFormat = &#39;Chicago&#39;" class="">Chicago</a></li> <li><a ng-class="{active: currentFormat == &#39;MLA&#39;}" ng-click="currentFormat = &#39;MLA&#39;" class="active">MLA</a></li> </ul> <div class="citations" ng-switch="currentFormat"> <!-- ngSwitchWhen: APA --> <!-- ngSwitchWhen: Bluebook --> <!-- ngSwitchWhen: Chicago --> <!-- ngSwitchWhen: MLA --><div ng-switch-when="MLA" class="ng-binding ng-scope"> "PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing." <i class="ng-binding">Oyez,</i> www.oyez.org/cases/2010/09-993. Accessed 17 Jul. 2019. </div><!-- end ngSwitchWhen: --> </div> </div> <div class="ng-isolate-scope"> <br><a href="https://www.oyez.org/feedback?referer=https://www.oyez.org/cases/2010/09-993">Report an error</a> </div> </div> </article> </main></div> </div> </div> <!-- ngIf: (! isApp) --><footer oy-height-report="offsetTop" ng-if="(! isApp)" class="ng-scope ng-isolate-scope"> <div class="wrapper"> <div class="left"> <!-- ngRepeat: logo in sponsorLogos --><a ng-href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/" target="_blank" ng-repeat="logo in sponsorLogos" class="lii" href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/"> <picture class="sponsor-logo"> <source media="(min-width: 64.0625em)" ng-srcset="images/footer/lii-lg.00e7f41d.png" srcset="images/footer/lii-lg.00e7f41d.png"> <source srcset="images/footer/lii-sm.600c96d2.png"> <img ng-src="images/footer/lii-sm.600c96d2.png" alt="Legal Information Institute" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/lii-sm.600c96d2.png"> </picture> </a><!-- end ngRepeat: logo in sponsorLogos --><a ng-href="http://www.lawschool.cornell.edu/" target="_blank" ng-repeat="logo in sponsorLogos" class="cls" href="http://www.lawschool.cornell.edu/"> <picture class="sponsor-logo"> <source media="(min-width: 64.0625em)" ng-srcset="images/footer/cls-lg.4e012d87.png" srcset="images/footer/cls-lg.4e012d87.png"> <source srcset="images/footer/cls-sm.adc9daa6.png"> <img ng-src="images/footer/cls-sm.adc9daa6.png" alt="Cornell Law School" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/cls-sm.adc9daa6.png"> </picture> </a><!-- end ngRepeat: logo in sponsorLogos --><a ng-href="https://www.justia.com/" target="_blank" ng-repeat="logo in sponsorLogos" class="justia" href="https://www.justia.com/"> <picture class="sponsor-logo"> <source media="(min-width: 64.0625em)" ng-srcset="images/footer/justia-lg.d30c9a79.svg" srcset="images/footer/justia-lg.d30c9a79.svg"> <source srcset="images/footer/justia-sm.8fe3b97e.png"> <img ng-src="images/footer/justia-sm.8fe3b97e.png" alt="Justia" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/justia-sm.8fe3b97e.png"> </picture> </a><!-- end ngRepeat: logo in sponsorLogos --><a ng-href="http://www.kentlaw.iit.edu/" target="_blank" ng-repeat="logo in sponsorLogos" class="iit" href="http://www.kentlaw.iit.edu/"> <picture class="sponsor-logo"> <source media="(min-width: 64.0625em)" ng-srcset="images/footer/iit-lg.c2647680.png" srcset="images/footer/iit-lg.c2647680.png"> <source srcset="images/footer/iit-sm.0aefde4c.png"> <img ng-src="images/footer/iit-sm.0aefde4c.png" alt="Illinois Institute of Technology" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/iit-sm.0aefde4c.png"> </picture> </a><!-- end ngRepeat: logo in sponsorLogos --> </div> <div class="right"> <!-- ngRepeat: icon in socialIcons --><a ng-href="https://www.facebook.com/OyezProject" target="_blank" ng-repeat="icon in socialIcons" class="social-icon ng-scope" href="https://www.facebook.com/OyezProject"> <img ng-src="/images/footer/social/facebook.e273257b.png" alt="Facebook" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/facebook.e273257b.png"> </a><!-- end ngRepeat: icon in socialIcons --><a ng-href="https://www.twitter.com/oyez" target="_blank" ng-repeat="icon in socialIcons" class="social-icon ng-scope" href="https://www.twitter.com/oyez"> <img ng-src="/images/footer/social/twitter.9691e770.png" alt="Twitter" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/twitter.9691e770.png"> </a><!-- end ngRepeat: icon in socialIcons --><a ng-href="https://itunes.apple.com/us/artist/oyez/id1035429757" target="_blank" ng-repeat="icon in socialIcons" class="social-icon ng-scope" href="https://itunes.apple.com/us/artist/oyez/id1035429757"> <img ng-src="/images/footer/social/podcast.ae544b59.png" alt="Podcast" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/podcast.ae544b59.png"> </a><!-- end ngRepeat: icon in socialIcons --><a ng-href="http://eepurl.com/gt517A" target="_blank" ng-repeat="icon in socialIcons" class="social-icon ng-scope" href="http://eepurl.com/gt517A"> <img ng-src="/images/footer/social/email.dcd23f4e.png" alt="Subscribe" src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/email.dcd23f4e.png"> </a><!-- end ngRepeat: icon in socialIcons --> </div> </div> </footer><!-- end ngIf: (! isApp) --> <!-- Google Analytics: change UA-XXXXX-X to be your site's ID --> <script>!function(A,n,g,u,l,a,r){A.GoogleAnalyticsObject=l,A[l]=A[l]||function(){ (A[l].q=A[l].q||[]).push(arguments)},A[l].l=+new Date,a=n.createElement(g), r=n.getElementsByTagName(g)[0],a.src=u,r.parentNode.insertBefore(a,r) }(window,document,'script','//www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js','ga'); ga('create', 'UA-1508262-2');</script> <!-- Google Tag Manager (noscript) --> <noscript><iframe src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-K9XPQSX" height="0" width="0" style="display:none;visibility:hidden"></iframe></noscript> <!-- End Google Tag Manager (noscript) --> <script src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/modernizr.min.js.download"></script> <script src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/vendor.c7f57539.js.download"></script> <script src="./PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez_files/scripts.bc383327.js.download"></script> </body></html> text/html"PLIVA, Inc. v. Mensing _ Oyez.html
    https://whatsonchain.com/tx/a56e175d0aa69f0720ea7dab2e76f84b42608616fe0c0c1424f671e7b05ee88e